{"vote_id":"VTANR5L17V5453","voted_at":"2026-02-17T00:00:00","vote_title":"l'amendement n° 82 de M. Clouet à l'article 4 bis de la proposition de loi visant à garantir l'égal accès de tous à l'accompagnement et aux soins palliatifs (deuxième lecture).","result":"rejeté","votes_for":49,"votes_against":105,"abstentions":18,"total_voters":172,"summary_plain":"L'amendement visait à modifier l'article 4 bis de la proposition de loi sur l'accès aux soins palliatifs, mais il a été rejeté, ce qui signifie que les dispositions initiales de l'article restent inchangées.","theme":"Santé & Social","vote_type":"spo","dossier_id":null,"ingested_at":null,"positions":[{"position_id":516207,"deputy_id":"PA793214","full_name":"Audrey Abadie-Amiel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516148,"deputy_id":"PA840665","full_name":"Marie-José Allemand","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516149,"deputy_id":"PA342415","full_name":"Marie-Noëlle Battistel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516150,"deputy_id":"PA841315","full_name":"Karim Benbrahim","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516151,"deputy_id":"PA793394","full_name":"Arthur Delaporte","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516152,"deputy_id":"PA795430","full_name":"Stéphane Delautrette","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516153,"deputy_id":"PA333285","full_name":"Guillaume Garot","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516154,"deputy_id":"PA331973","full_name":"Pascale Got","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516155,"deputy_id":"PA774958","full_name":"Gérard Leseul","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516156,"deputy_id":"PA841107","full_name":"Jacques Oberti","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516157,"deputy_id":"PA841381","full_name":"Sophie Pantel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516158,"deputy_id":"PA608172","full_name":"Christine Pirès Beaune","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516159,"deputy_id":"PA840673","full_name":"Valérie Rossi","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516160,"deputy_id":"PA342196","full_name":"Claudia Rouaux","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516161,"deputy_id":"PA826635","full_name":"Aurélien Rousseau","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516162,"deputy_id":"PA841717","full_name":"Sandrine Runel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516163,"deputy_id":"PA340343","full_name":"Hervé Saulignac","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516164,"deputy_id":"PA841091","full_name":"Arnaud Simion","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":516188,"deputy_id":"PA720256","full_name":"Géraldine Bannier","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516047,"deputy_id":"PA793374","full_name":"Romain Baubry","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516165,"deputy_id":"PA642847","full_name":"Thibault Bazin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516195,"deputy_id":"PA332228","full_name":"Thierry Benoit","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516048,"deputy_id":"PA794434","full_name":"Christophe Bentz","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516193,"deputy_id":"PA805166","full_name":"Anne Bergantz","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516196,"deputy_id":"PA687214","full_name":"Sylvain Berrios","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516216,"deputy_id":"PA309643","full_name":"Véronique Besse","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516208,"deputy_id":"PA840889","full_name":"Matthieu Bloch","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516166,"deputy_id":"PA721410","full_name":"Émilie Bonnivard","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516093,"deputy_id":"PA717161","full_name":"Élisabeth Borne","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516094,"deputy_id":"PA642695","full_name":"Éric Bothorel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516049,"deputy_id":"PA841131","full_name":"Manon Bouquin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516050,"deputy_id":"PA793182","full_name":"Jorys Bovet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516167,"deputy_id":"PA793508","full_name":"Hubert Brigand","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516202,"deputy_id":"PA840817","full_name":"Joël Bruneau","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516095,"deputy_id":"PA794798","full_name":"Françoise Buffet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516214,"deputy_id":"PA841973","full_name":"Pierre-Henri Carbonnel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516051,"deputy_id":"PA840075","full_name":"Eddy Casterman","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516096,"deputy_id":"PA842311","full_name":"Vincent Caure","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516097,"deputy_id":"PA719472","full_name":"Jean-René Cazeneuve","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516209,"deputy_id":"PA840701","full_name":"Bernard Chaix","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516052,"deputy_id":"PA794198","full_name":"Roger Chudeau","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516110,"deputy_id":"PA795402","full_name":"Nathalie Coggia","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516189,"deputy_id":"PA793520","full_name":"Mickaël Cosson","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516053,"deputy_id":"PA795644","full_name":"Nathalie Da Conceicao Carvalho","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516203,"deputy_id":"PA942","full_name":"Charles de Courson","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516054,"deputy_id":"PA841613","full_name":"Marc de Fleurian","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516055,"deputy_id":"PA642988","full_name":"Hervé de Lépinau","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516204,"deputy_id":"PA841359","full_name":"Constance de Pélichy","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516168,"deputy_id":"PA330909","full_name":"Vincent Descoeur","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516056,"deputy_id":"PA794762","full_name":"Sandrine Dogor-Such","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516098,"deputy_id":"PA720154","full_name":"Nicole Dubré-Chirat","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516057,"deputy_id":"PA840135","full_name":"Alexandre Dufosset","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516175,"deputy_id":"PA870009","full_name":"Lionel Duparay","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516058,"deputy_id":"PA841761","full_name":"Aurélien Dutremble","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516217,"deputy_id":"PA794718","full_name":"Christine Engrand","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516197,"deputy_id":"PA794658","full_name":"Philippe Fait","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516059,"deputy_id":"PA793246","full_name":"Frédéric Falcon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516190,"deputy_id":"PA605694","full_name":"Olivier Falorni","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516205,"deputy_id":"PA267042","full_name":"Yannick Favennec-Bécot","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516210,"deputy_id":"PA840773","full_name":"Olivier Fayssat","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516198,"deputy_id":"PA267780","full_name":"Agnès Firmin Le Bodo","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516060,"deputy_id":"PA840143","full_name":"Guillaume Florquin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516061,"deputy_id":"PA794678","full_name":"Thierry Frappé","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516176,"deputy_id":"PA841151","full_name":"Alix Fruchon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516062,"deputy_id":"PA793892","full_name":"Stéphanie Galzy","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516199,"deputy_id":"PA794234","full_name":"François Gernigon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516063,"deputy_id":"PA841737","full_name":"Jonathan Gery","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516064,"deputy_id":"PA796034","full_name":"Frank Giletti","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516065,"deputy_id":"PA793362","full_name":"José Gonzalez","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516066,"deputy_id":"PA794418","full_name":"Florence Goulet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516218,"deputy_id":"PA795540","full_name":"Daniel Grenon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516169,"deputy_id":"PA794058","full_name":"Justine Gruet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516072,"deputy_id":"PA793218","full_name":"Jordan Guitton","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516073,"deputy_id":"PA795900","full_name":"Marine Hamelet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516170,"deputy_id":"PA608416","full_name":"Patrick Hetzel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516074,"deputy_id":"PA842085","full_name":"Sébastien Humbert","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516075,"deputy_id":"PA794598","full_name":"Laurent Jacobelli","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516076,"deputy_id":"PA841749","full_name":"Tiffany Joncour","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516077,"deputy_id":"PA840869","full_name":"Florence Joubert","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516171,"deputy_id":"PA346782","full_name":"Philippe Juvin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516103,"deputy_id":"PA643184","full_name":"Brigitte Klinkert","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516200,"deputy_id":"PA842125","full_name":"Thomas Lam","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516104,"deputy_id":"PA720022","full_name":"Michel Lauzzana","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516078,"deputy_id":"PA841837","full_name":"Robert Le Bourgeois","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516172,"deputy_id":"PA840979","full_name":"Corentin Le Fur","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516174,"deputy_id":"PA642725","full_name":"Eric Liégeon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516079,"deputy_id":"PA841873","full_name":"Julien Limongi","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516080,"deputy_id":"PA793672","full_name":"Christine Loir","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516081,"deputy_id":"PA721932","full_name":"Marie-France Lorho","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516082,"deputy_id":"PA841587","full_name":"David Magnier","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516083,"deputy_id":"PA841563","full_name":"Claire Marais-Beuil","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516105,"deputy_id":"PA795730","full_name":"Bastien Marchive","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516084,"deputy_id":"PA840837","full_name":"Pascal Markowsky","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516106,"deputy_id":"PA719080","full_name":"Sandra Marsaud","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516085,"deputy_id":"PA841825","full_name":"Patrice Martin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516191,"deputy_id":"PA795100","full_name":"Éric Martineau","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516086,"deputy_id":"PA793616","full_name":"Kévin Mauvieux","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516107,"deputy_id":"PA719338","full_name":"Graziella Melchior","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516087,"deputy_id":"PA794322","full_name":"Thomas Ménagé","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516173,"deputy_id":"PA719272","full_name":"Frédérique Meunier","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516108,"deputy_id":"PA795664","full_name":"Paul Midy","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516102,"deputy_id":"PA842147","full_name":"Christophe Mongardien","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516192,"deputy_id":"PA794810","full_name":"Louise Morel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516206,"deputy_id":"PA721486","full_name":"Christophe Naegelen","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516088,"deputy_id":"PA794582","full_name":"Kévin Pfeffer","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516089,"deputy_id":"PA793656","full_name":"Lisette Pollet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516109,"deputy_id":"PA721916","full_name":"Natalia Pouzyreff","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516090,"deputy_id":"PA795966","full_name":"Stéphane Rambaud","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516091,"deputy_id":"PA793254","full_name":"Julien Rancoule","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516212,"deputy_id":"PA840657","full_name":"Sophie Ricourt Vaginay","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516092,"deputy_id":"PA841981","full_name":"Catherine Rimbert","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516099,"deputy_id":"PA793270","full_name":"Jean-François Rousset","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516067,"deputy_id":"PA842097","full_name":"Sophie-Laurence Roy","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516068,"deputy_id":"PA794954","full_name":"Emeric Salmon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516069,"deputy_id":"PA842255","full_name":"Anne Sicard","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516100,"deputy_id":"PA720190","full_name":"Bertrand Sorre","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516070,"deputy_id":"PA840781","full_name":"Romain Tonussi","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516211,"deputy_id":"PA840685","full_name":"Vincent Trébuchet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516201,"deputy_id":"PA795350","full_name":"Frédéric Valletoux","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516213,"deputy_id":"PA840809","full_name":"Gérault Verny","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516101,"deputy_id":"PA722102","full_name":"Annie Vidal","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516071,"deputy_id":"PA794946","full_name":"Antoine Villedieu","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516219,"deputy_id":"PA793194","full_name":"Lionel Vuibert","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":516111,"deputy_id":"PA721908","full_name":"Yaël Braun-Pivet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"nonVotant"},{"position_id":5579673,"deputy_id":"PA720066","full_name":"Stéphanie Rist","party_short":"PO838901","position":"nonVotant"},{"position_id":516112,"deputy_id":"PA794138","full_name":"Ségolène Amiot","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516135,"deputy_id":"PA840829","full_name":"Fabrice Barusseau","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516113,"deputy_id":"PA720430","full_name":"Ugo Bernalicis","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516114,"deputy_id":"PA793772","full_name":"Christophe Bex","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516177,"deputy_id":"PA840997","full_name":"Benoît Biteau","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516179,"deputy_id":"PA841507","full_name":"Nicolas Bonnet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516178,"deputy_id":"PA841885","full_name":"Arnaud Bonnet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516194,"deputy_id":"PA841339","full_name":"Jean-Michel Brard","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516136,"deputy_id":"PA795762","full_name":"Elie Califer","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516180,"deputy_id":"PA794008","full_name":"Cyrielle Chatelain","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516115,"deputy_id":"PA793736","full_name":"Hadrien Clouet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516116,"deputy_id":"PA795136","full_name":"Jean-François Coulomme","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516137,"deputy_id":"PA841919","full_name":"Dieynaba Diop","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516138,"deputy_id":"PA606573","full_name":"Fanny Dombre Coste","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516139,"deputy_id":"PA841633","full_name":"Peio Dufau","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516117,"deputy_id":"PA795200","full_name":"Alma Dufour","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516181,"deputy_id":"PA841351","full_name":"Emmanuel Duplessy","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516118,"deputy_id":"PA795844","full_name":"Karen Erodi","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516140,"deputy_id":"PA841665","full_name":"Denis Fégné","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516119,"deputy_id":"PA794786","full_name":"Emmanuel Fernandes","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516120,"deputy_id":"PA794870","full_name":"Sylvie Ferrer","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516124,"deputy_id":"PA841947","full_name":"Zahia Hamdane","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516182,"deputy_id":"PA840947","full_name":"Catherine Hervieu","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516125,"deputy_id":"PA794082","full_name":"Mathilde Hignet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516142,"deputy_id":"PA643192","full_name":"Chantal Jourdan","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516126,"deputy_id":"PA795516","full_name":"Maxime Laisney","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516127,"deputy_id":"PA795672","full_name":"Arnaud Le Gall","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516128,"deputy_id":"PA795108","full_name":"Élise Leboucher","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516129,"deputy_id":"PA791824","full_name":"Sarah Legrain","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516130,"deputy_id":"PA793532","full_name":"Murielle Lepvraud","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516143,"deputy_id":"PA840765","full_name":"Laurent Lhardit","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516131,"deputy_id":"PA342384","full_name":"Élisa Martin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516144,"deputy_id":"PA841463","full_name":"Estelle Mercier","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516132,"deputy_id":"PA841191","full_name":"Sandrine Nosbé","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516183,"deputy_id":"PA793708","full_name":"Sébastien Peytavie","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516145,"deputy_id":"PA794270","full_name":"Anna Pic","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516133,"deputy_id":"PA817211","full_name":"René Pilato","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516146,"deputy_id":"PA840955","full_name":"Pierre Pribetich","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516147,"deputy_id":"PA841367","full_name":"Christophe Proença","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516134,"deputy_id":"PA721062","full_name":"Jean-Hugues Ratenon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516184,"deputy_id":"PA794154","full_name":"Jean-Claude Raux","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516185,"deputy_id":"PA795076","full_name":"Sandrine Rousseau","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516186,"deputy_id":"PA795808","full_name":"Sabrina Sebaihi","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516187,"deputy_id":"PA796018","full_name":"Danielle Simonnet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516121,"deputy_id":"PA795466","full_name":"Ersilia Soudais","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516122,"deputy_id":"PA793744","full_name":"Anne Stambach-Terrenoir","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516123,"deputy_id":"PA794166","full_name":"Matthias Tavel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516141,"deputy_id":"PA841893","full_name":"Céline Thiébault-Martinez","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":516215,"deputy_id":"PA842299","full_name":"Emmanuel Tjibaou","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"}]}