{"vote_id":"VTANR5L17V5938","voted_at":"2026-03-31T00:00:00","vote_title":"l'amendement n° 49 de Mme Runel et l'amendement identique suivant de suppression de l'article 12 bis C du projet de loi relatif à la lutte contre les fraudes sociales et fiscales (première lecture).","result":"rejeté","votes_for":38,"votes_against":94,"abstentions":1,"total_voters":133,"summary_plain":"L'amendement visait à supprimer l'article 12 bis C du projet de loi contre les fraudes sociales et fiscales, mais il a été rejeté.","theme":"Justice & Sécurité","vote_type":"spo","dossier_id":"{'libelle': 'Projet de loi relatif à la lutte contre les fraudes sociales et fiscales', 'dossierRef': 'DLR5L17N52985'}","ingested_at":null,"positions":[{"position_id":99925,"deputy_id":"PA857021","full_name":"Alim Latrèche","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":99992,"deputy_id":"PA841067","full_name":"Alexandre Allegret-Pilot","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99865,"deputy_id":"PA793374","full_name":"Romain Baubry","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99957,"deputy_id":"PA642847","full_name":"Thibault Bazin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99866,"deputy_id":"PA793158","full_name":"José Beaurain","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99979,"deputy_id":"PA795278","full_name":"Béatrice Bellamy","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99980,"deputy_id":"PA332228","full_name":"Thierry Benoit","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99978,"deputy_id":"PA805166","full_name":"Anne Bergantz","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99867,"deputy_id":"PA841645","full_name":"Théo Bernhardt","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99907,"deputy_id":"PA719218","full_name":"Hervé Berville","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99868,"deputy_id":"PA794886","full_name":"Sophie Blanc","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99988,"deputy_id":"PA842183","full_name":"Benoît Blanchard","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99993,"deputy_id":"PA840889","full_name":"Matthieu Bloch","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99958,"deputy_id":"PA719968","full_name":"Sylvie Bonnet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99959,"deputy_id":"PA721816","full_name":"Ian Boucard","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99960,"deputy_id":"PA342240","full_name":"Jean-Luc Bourgeaux","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99981,"deputy_id":"PA841339","full_name":"Jean-Michel Brard","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99961,"deputy_id":"PA793508","full_name":"Hubert Brigand","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99908,"deputy_id":"PA794330","full_name":"Anthony Brosse","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99909,"deputy_id":"PA719890","full_name":"Danielle Brulebois","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99910,"deputy_id":"PA794798","full_name":"Françoise Buffet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99869,"deputy_id":"PA793134","full_name":"Jérôme Buisson","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99996,"deputy_id":"PA841973","full_name":"Pierre-Henri Carbonnel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99994,"deputy_id":"PA840721","full_name":"Marc Chavent","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99870,"deputy_id":"PA794198","full_name":"Roger Chudeau","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99982,"deputy_id":"PA841431","full_name":"Nathalie Colin-Oesterlé","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99962,"deputy_id":"PA332523","full_name":"Marie-Christine Dalloz","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99968,"deputy_id":"PA842141","full_name":"Élisabeth de Maistre","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99871,"deputy_id":"PA793928","full_name":"Edwige Diaz","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99963,"deputy_id":"PA712015","full_name":"Julien Dive","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99872,"deputy_id":"PA794762","full_name":"Sandrine Dogor-Such","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99873,"deputy_id":"PA793146","full_name":"Nicolas Dragon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99997,"deputy_id":"PA794718","full_name":"Christine Engrand","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99983,"deputy_id":"PA794658","full_name":"Philippe Fait","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99874,"deputy_id":"PA793246","full_name":"Frédéric Falcon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99995,"deputy_id":"PA840773","full_name":"Olivier Fayssat","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99984,"deputy_id":"PA794470","full_name":"Félicie Gérard","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99875,"deputy_id":"PA841737","full_name":"Jonathan Gery","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99876,"deputy_id":"PA796034","full_name":"Frank Giletti","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99877,"deputy_id":"PA793832","full_name":"Yoann Gillet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99878,"deputy_id":"PA793102","full_name":"Christian Girard","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99879,"deputy_id":"PA841605","full_name":"Antoine Golliot","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99880,"deputy_id":"PA793362","full_name":"José Gonzalez","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99881,"deputy_id":"PA794418","full_name":"Florence Goulet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99884,"deputy_id":"PA841451","full_name":"Julien Guibert","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99885,"deputy_id":"PA793218","full_name":"Jordan Guitton","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99964,"deputy_id":"PA608416","full_name":"Patrick Hetzel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99886,"deputy_id":"PA793632","full_name":"Timothée Houssin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99887,"deputy_id":"PA842085","full_name":"Sébastien Humbert","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99914,"deputy_id":"PA267200","full_name":"Sébastien Huyghe","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99985,"deputy_id":"PA719778","full_name":"François Jolivet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99888,"deputy_id":"PA841749","full_name":"Tiffany Joncour","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99915,"deputy_id":"PA643184","full_name":"Brigitte Klinkert","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99916,"deputy_id":"PA719798","full_name":"Daniel Labaronne","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99986,"deputy_id":"PA842125","full_name":"Thomas Lam","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99889,"deputy_id":"PA841837","full_name":"Robert Le Bourgeois","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99917,"deputy_id":"PA719404","full_name":"Didier Le Gac","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99967,"deputy_id":"PA642725","full_name":"Eric Liégeon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99975,"deputy_id":"PA794702","full_name":"Delphine Lingemann","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99890,"deputy_id":"PA840967","full_name":"René Lioret","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99918,"deputy_id":"PA720446","full_name":"Brigitte Liso","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99891,"deputy_id":"PA793672","full_name":"Christine Loir","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99892,"deputy_id":"PA721932","full_name":"Marie-France Lorho","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99893,"deputy_id":"PA795974","full_name":"Philippe Lottiaux","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99924,"deputy_id":"PA879389","full_name":"Marie-Philippe Lubet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99894,"deputy_id":"PA841587","full_name":"David Magnier","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99919,"deputy_id":"PA795730","full_name":"Bastien Marchive","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99895,"deputy_id":"PA840837","full_name":"Pascal Markowsky","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99896,"deputy_id":"PA841825","full_name":"Patrice Martin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99976,"deputy_id":"PA795100","full_name":"Éric Martineau","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99920,"deputy_id":"PA720146","full_name":"Denis Masséglia","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99897,"deputy_id":"PA793616","full_name":"Kévin Mauvieux","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99990,"deputy_id":"PA841931","full_name":"Laurent Mazaury","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99921,"deputy_id":"PA720370","full_name":"Ludovic Mendes","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99898,"deputy_id":"PA793852","full_name":"Pierre Meurin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99922,"deputy_id":"PA817203","full_name":"Laure Miller","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99969,"deputy_id":"PA643104","full_name":"Christelle Minard","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99899,"deputy_id":"PA793696","full_name":"Serge Muller","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99965,"deputy_id":"PA718784","full_name":"Éric Pauget","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99900,"deputy_id":"PA841199","full_name":"Thierry Perez","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99901,"deputy_id":"PA793656","full_name":"Lisette Pollet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99902,"deputy_id":"PA793254","full_name":"Julien Rancoule","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99966,"deputy_id":"PA793094","full_name":"Nicolas Ray","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99903,"deputy_id":"PA841955","full_name":"Matthias Renault","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99904,"deputy_id":"PA841981","full_name":"Catherine Rimbert","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99905,"deputy_id":"PA794442","full_name":"Laurence Robert-Dehault","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99923,"deputy_id":"PA795528","full_name":"Charles Rodwell","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99911,"deputy_id":"PA793270","full_name":"Jean-François Rousset","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99882,"deputy_id":"PA794570","full_name":"Alexandre Sabatou","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99912,"deputy_id":"PA794802","full_name":"Charles Sitzenstuhl","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99883,"deputy_id":"PA793382","full_name":"Emmanuel Taché","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99977,"deputy_id":"PA719822","full_name":"Sabine Thillaye","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99987,"deputy_id":"PA795350","full_name":"Frédéric Valletoux","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99913,"deputy_id":"PA719512","full_name":"Corinne Vignon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99998,"deputy_id":"PA793194","full_name":"Lionel Vuibert","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":99926,"deputy_id":"PA721908","full_name":"Yaël Braun-Pivet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"nonVotant"},{"position_id":99946,"deputy_id":"PA840665","full_name":"Marie-José Allemand","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99970,"deputy_id":"PA610968","full_name":"Pouria Amirshahi","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99947,"deputy_id":"PA606793","full_name":"Laurent Baumel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99948,"deputy_id":"PA720362","full_name":"Belkhir Belhaddad","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99927,"deputy_id":"PA720430","full_name":"Ugo Bernalicis","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99928,"deputy_id":"PA795318","full_name":"Louis Boyard","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99929,"deputy_id":"PA841023","full_name":"Pierre-Yves Cadalen","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99930,"deputy_id":"PA842187","full_name":"Gabrielle Cathala","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99971,"deputy_id":"PA794008","full_name":"Cyrielle Chatelain","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99931,"deputy_id":"PA791812","full_name":"Sophia Chikirou","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99989,"deputy_id":"PA841359","full_name":"Constance de Pélichy","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99932,"deputy_id":"PA795844","full_name":"Karen Erodi","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99933,"deputy_id":"PA841251","full_name":"Mathilde Feld","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99934,"deputy_id":"PA794786","full_name":"Emmanuel Fernandes","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99935,"deputy_id":"PA794870","full_name":"Sylvie Ferrer","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99972,"deputy_id":"PA795010","full_name":"Marie-Charlotte Garin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99937,"deputy_id":"PA795310","full_name":"Clémence Guetté","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99951,"deputy_id":"PA643192","full_name":"Chantal Jourdan","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99991,"deputy_id":"PA774962","full_name":"Karine Lebon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99938,"deputy_id":"PA795298","full_name":"Jérôme Legavre","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99939,"deputy_id":"PA793532","full_name":"Murielle Lepvraud","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99940,"deputy_id":"PA342384","full_name":"Élisa Martin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99941,"deputy_id":"PA794686","full_name":"Marianne Maximi","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99942,"deputy_id":"PA841191","full_name":"Sandrine Nosbé","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99952,"deputy_id":"PA841107","full_name":"Jacques Oberti","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99943,"deputy_id":"PA793872","full_name":"Nathalie Oziol","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99953,"deputy_id":"PA840793","full_name":"Marc Pena","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99944,"deputy_id":"PA817211","full_name":"René Pilato","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99945,"deputy_id":"PA796062","full_name":"Thomas Portes","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99954,"deputy_id":"PA841367","full_name":"Christophe Proença","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99973,"deputy_id":"PA794778","full_name":"Sandra Regol","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99955,"deputy_id":"PA342196","full_name":"Claudia Rouaux","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99956,"deputy_id":"PA841327","full_name":"Fabrice Roussel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99949,"deputy_id":"PA841717","full_name":"Sandrine Runel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99950,"deputy_id":"PA841243","full_name":"Sébastien Saint-Pasteur","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99906,"deputy_id":"PA720190","full_name":"Bertrand Sorre","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99936,"deputy_id":"PA794106","full_name":"Andrée Taurinya","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":99974,"deputy_id":"PA841713","full_name":"Boris Tavernier","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"}]}