{"vote_id":"VTANR5L17V7513","voted_at":"2026-06-24T00:00:00","vote_title":"l'amendement n° 38 de M. Hetzel et l'amendement identique suivant à l’article 4 de la proposition de loi relative au droit à l’aide à mourir (nouvelle lecture).","result":"rejeté","votes_for":68,"votes_against":102,"abstentions":1,"total_voters":171,"summary_plain":null,"theme":null,"vote_type":"spo","dossier_id":"{'libelle': 'Fin de vie', 'dossierRef': 'DLR5L17N51670'}","ingested_at":null,"positions":[{"position_id":5677931,"deputy_id":"PA841431","full_name":"Nathalie Colin-Oesterlé","party_short":"PO838901","position":"abstention"},{"position_id":5677933,"deputy_id":"PA793214","full_name":"Audrey Abadie-Amiel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677844,"deputy_id":"PA795228","full_name":"Nadège Abomangoli","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677845,"deputy_id":"PA794906","full_name":"Gabriel Amard","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677846,"deputy_id":"PA795588","full_name":"Farida Amrani","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677821,"deputy_id":"PA721158","full_name":"Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677847,"deputy_id":"PA842105","full_name":"Raphaël Arnault","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677864,"deputy_id":"PA840829","full_name":"Fabrice Barusseau","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677865,"deputy_id":"PA342415","full_name":"Marie-Noëlle Battistel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677866,"deputy_id":"PA606793","full_name":"Laurent Baumel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677911,"deputy_id":"PA795454","full_name":"Karim Ben Cheikh","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677867,"deputy_id":"PA841315","full_name":"Karim Benbrahim","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677897,"deputy_id":"PA840175","full_name":"Dorine Bregman","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677822,"deputy_id":"PA794330","full_name":"Anthony Brosse","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677823,"deputy_id":"PA794798","full_name":"Françoise Buffet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677824,"deputy_id":"PA721750","full_name":"Céline Calvez","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677848,"deputy_id":"PA793912","full_name":"Sylvain Carrière","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677830,"deputy_id":"PA841801","full_name":"Danièle Carteron","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677839,"deputy_id":"PA718820","full_name":"Pauline Cestrières","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677825,"deputy_id":"PA719118","full_name":"François Cormier-Bouligeon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677919,"deputy_id":"PA719914","full_name":"Geneviève Darrieussecq","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677868,"deputy_id":"PA793394","full_name":"Arthur Delaporte","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677869,"deputy_id":"PA795430","full_name":"Stéphane Delautrette","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677826,"deputy_id":"PA794982","full_name":"Julie Delpech","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677870,"deputy_id":"PA606573","full_name":"Fanny Dombre Coste","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677827,"deputy_id":"PA720154","full_name":"Nicole Dubré-Chirat","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677813,"deputy_id":"PA840135","full_name":"Alexandre Dufosset","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677814,"deputy_id":"PA842073","full_name":"Gaëtan Dussausaye","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677871,"deputy_id":"PA794854","full_name":"Iñaki Echaniz","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677849,"deputy_id":"PA795844","full_name":"Karen Erodi","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677942,"deputy_id":"PA607193","full_name":"Sophie Errante","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677872,"deputy_id":"PA842195","full_name":"Romain Eskenazi","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677873,"deputy_id":"PA841665","full_name":"Denis Fégné","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677850,"deputy_id":"PA841251","full_name":"Mathilde Feld","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677851,"deputy_id":"PA794786","full_name":"Emmanuel Fernandes","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677925,"deputy_id":"PA267780","full_name":"Agnès Firmin Le Bodo","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677874,"deputy_id":"PA822617","full_name":"Martine Froger","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677828,"deputy_id":"PA722366","full_name":"Jean-Luc Fugit","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677875,"deputy_id":"PA333285","full_name":"Guillaume Garot","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677926,"deputy_id":"PA794234","full_name":"François Gernigon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677923,"deputy_id":"PA793556","full_name":"Sabine Gervais","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677876,"deputy_id":"PA840939","full_name":"Océane Godard","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677877,"deputy_id":"PA331973","full_name":"Pascale Got","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677853,"deputy_id":"PA795310","full_name":"Clémence Guetté","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677912,"deputy_id":"PA842013","full_name":"Steevy Gustave","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677885,"deputy_id":"PA842263","full_name":"Ayda Hadizadeh","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677886,"deputy_id":"PA841813","full_name":"Florence Herouin-Léautey","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677887,"deputy_id":"PA841853","full_name":"Céline Hervieu","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677913,"deputy_id":"PA794022","full_name":"Jérémie Iordanoff","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677927,"deputy_id":"PA719052","full_name":"Loïc Kervran","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677854,"deputy_id":"PA720846","full_name":"Bastien Lachaud","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677841,"deputy_id":"PA857021","full_name":"Alim Latrèche","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677832,"deputy_id":"PA720022","full_name":"Michel Lauzzana","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677934,"deputy_id":"PA774962","full_name":"Karine Lebon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677855,"deputy_id":"PA795108","full_name":"Élise Leboucher","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677856,"deputy_id":"PA791824","full_name":"Sarah Legrain","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677932,"deputy_id":"PA795244","full_name":"Stéphane Lenormand","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677857,"deputy_id":"PA793532","full_name":"Murielle Lepvraud","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677888,"deputy_id":"PA774958","full_name":"Gérard Leseul","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677889,"deputy_id":"PA840765","full_name":"Laurent Lhardit","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677833,"deputy_id":"PA720446","full_name":"Brigitte Liso","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677842,"deputy_id":"PA879389","full_name":"Marie-Philippe Lubet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677834,"deputy_id":"PA795730","full_name":"Bastien Marchive","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677930,"deputy_id":"PA794518","full_name":"Pierre Marle","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677858,"deputy_id":"PA795422","full_name":"Damien Maudet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677859,"deputy_id":"PA794686","full_name":"Marianne Maximi","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677835,"deputy_id":"PA719338","full_name":"Graziella Melchior","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677831,"deputy_id":"PA842147","full_name":"Christophe Mongardien","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677935,"deputy_id":"PA793174","full_name":"Yannick Monnet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677936,"deputy_id":"PA795820","full_name":"Marcellin Nadeau","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677860,"deputy_id":"PA841191","full_name":"Sandrine Nosbé","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677890,"deputy_id":"PA841107","full_name":"Jacques Oberti","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677836,"deputy_id":"PA759832","full_name":"Agnès Pannier-Runacher","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677928,"deputy_id":"PA720480","full_name":"Charlotte Parmentier-Lecocq","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677920,"deputy_id":"PA721182","full_name":"Frédéric Petit","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677914,"deputy_id":"PA793708","full_name":"Sébastien Peytavie","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677815,"deputy_id":"PA794582","full_name":"Kévin Pfeffer","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677891,"deputy_id":"PA794270","full_name":"Anna Pic","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677861,"deputy_id":"PA817211","full_name":"René Pilato","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677892,"deputy_id":"PA608172","full_name":"Christine Pirès Beaune","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677837,"deputy_id":"PA721916","full_name":"Natalia Pouzyreff","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677893,"deputy_id":"PA840955","full_name":"Pierre Pribetich","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677894,"deputy_id":"PA841367","full_name":"Christophe Proença","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677862,"deputy_id":"PA721062","full_name":"Jean-Hugues Ratenon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677838,"deputy_id":"PA722252","full_name":"Marie-Pierre Rixain","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677895,"deputy_id":"PA342196","full_name":"Claudia Rouaux","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677896,"deputy_id":"PA841327","full_name":"Fabrice Roussel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677829,"deputy_id":"PA793270","full_name":"Jean-François Rousset","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677878,"deputy_id":"PA841717","full_name":"Sandrine Runel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677879,"deputy_id":"PA841243","full_name":"Sébastien Saint-Pasteur","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677880,"deputy_id":"PA774960","full_name":"Isabelle Santiago","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677881,"deputy_id":"PA841091","full_name":"Arnaud Simion","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677915,"deputy_id":"PA796018","full_name":"Danielle Simonnet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677882,"deputy_id":"PA841681","full_name":"Thierry Sother","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677852,"deputy_id":"PA793744","full_name":"Anne Stambach-Terrenoir","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677883,"deputy_id":"PA841893","full_name":"Céline Thiébault-Martinez","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677916,"deputy_id":"PA793948","full_name":"Nicolas Thierry","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677921,"deputy_id":"PA722162","full_name":"Nicolas Turquois","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677884,"deputy_id":"PA719930","full_name":"Boris Vallaud","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677929,"deputy_id":"PA795350","full_name":"Frédéric Valletoux","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677922,"deputy_id":"PA331582","full_name":"Philippe Vigier","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677917,"deputy_id":"PA2940","full_name":"Dominique Voynet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677840,"deputy_id":"PA795326","full_name":"Christopher Weissberg","party_short":"PO838901","position":"contre"},{"position_id":5677843,"deputy_id":"PA721908","full_name":"Yaël Braun-Pivet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"nonVotant"},{"position_id":5677771,"deputy_id":"PA796118","full_name":"Bénédicte Auzanot","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677898,"deputy_id":"PA642847","full_name":"Thibault Bazin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677899,"deputy_id":"PA718884","full_name":"Valérie Bazin-Malgras","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677772,"deputy_id":"PA793158","full_name":"José Beaurain","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677773,"deputy_id":"PA794434","full_name":"Christophe Bentz","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677774,"deputy_id":"PA841645","full_name":"Théo Bernhardt","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677775,"deputy_id":"PA794886","full_name":"Sophie Blanc","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677900,"deputy_id":"PA774954","full_name":"Anne-Laure Blin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677901,"deputy_id":"PA719968","full_name":"Sylvie Bonnet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677776,"deputy_id":"PA841131","full_name":"Manon Bouquin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677777,"deputy_id":"PA793182","full_name":"Jorys Bovet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677778,"deputy_id":"PA793134","full_name":"Jérôme Buisson","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677941,"deputy_id":"PA841973","full_name":"Pierre-Henri Carbonnel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677779,"deputy_id":"PA840075","full_name":"Eddy Casterman","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677937,"deputy_id":"PA840701","full_name":"Bernard Chaix","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677938,"deputy_id":"PA840721","full_name":"Marc Chavent","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677780,"deputy_id":"PA793548","full_name":"Caroline Colombier","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677902,"deputy_id":"PA718850","full_name":"Pierre Cordier","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677781,"deputy_id":"PA795644","full_name":"Nathalie Da Conceicao Carvalho","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677903,"deputy_id":"PA332523","full_name":"Marie-Christine Dalloz","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677782,"deputy_id":"PA642988","full_name":"Hervé de Lépinau","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677909,"deputy_id":"PA842141","full_name":"Élisabeth de Maistre","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677810,"deputy_id":"PA841059","full_name":"Catherine Dellong Meng","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677783,"deputy_id":"PA793928","full_name":"Edwige Diaz","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677784,"deputy_id":"PA794762","full_name":"Sandrine Dogor-Such","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677785,"deputy_id":"PA793146","full_name":"Nicolas Dragon","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677910,"deputy_id":"PA870009","full_name":"Lionel Duparay","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677786,"deputy_id":"PA794678","full_name":"Thierry Frappé","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677787,"deputy_id":"PA841139","full_name":"Julien Gabarron","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677788,"deputy_id":"PA796034","full_name":"Frank Giletti","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677789,"deputy_id":"PA793102","full_name":"Christian Girard","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677790,"deputy_id":"PA793362","full_name":"José Gonzalez","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677904,"deputy_id":"PA794058","full_name":"Justine Gruet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677795,"deputy_id":"PA841451","full_name":"Julien Guibert","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677796,"deputy_id":"PA794734","full_name":"Michel Guiniot","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677797,"deputy_id":"PA795900","full_name":"Marine Hamelet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677905,"deputy_id":"PA608416","full_name":"Patrick Hetzel","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677798,"deputy_id":"PA841749","full_name":"Tiffany Joncour","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677811,"deputy_id":"PA840745","full_name":"Édouard Jordan","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677906,"deputy_id":"PA346782","full_name":"Philippe Juvin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677924,"deputy_id":"PA842125","full_name":"Thomas Lam","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677907,"deputy_id":"PA840979","full_name":"Corentin Le Fur","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677939,"deputy_id":"PA840983","full_name":"Bartolomé Lenoir","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677799,"deputy_id":"PA793608","full_name":"Katiana Levavasseur","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677800,"deputy_id":"PA721932","full_name":"Marie-France Lorho","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677801,"deputy_id":"PA795974","full_name":"Philippe Lottiaux","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677802,"deputy_id":"PA841563","full_name":"Claire Marais-Beuil","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677803,"deputy_id":"PA841825","full_name":"Patrice Martin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677804,"deputy_id":"PA793616","full_name":"Kévin Mauvieux","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677805,"deputy_id":"PA793852","full_name":"Pierre Meurin","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677819,"deputy_id":"PA795962","full_name":"Joséphine Missoffe","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677806,"deputy_id":"PA840915","full_name":"Thibaut Monnier","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677820,"deputy_id":"PA795050","full_name":"Astrid Panosyan-Bouvet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677807,"deputy_id":"PA793656","full_name":"Lisette Pollet","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677863,"deputy_id":"PA607553","full_name":"Dominique Potier","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677940,"deputy_id":"PA840657","full_name":"Sophie Ricourt Vaginay","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677808,"deputy_id":"PA841981","full_name":"Catherine Rimbert","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677809,"deputy_id":"PA794442","full_name":"Laurence Robert-Dehault","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677791,"deputy_id":"PA842097","full_name":"Sophie-Laurence Roy","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677792,"deputy_id":"PA794894","full_name":"Anaïs Sabatini","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677793,"deputy_id":"PA842255","full_name":"Anne Sicard","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677816,"deputy_id":"PA794802","full_name":"Charles Sitzenstuhl","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677817,"deputy_id":"PA719550","full_name":"Liliana Tanguy","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677918,"deputy_id":"PA719822","full_name":"Sabine Thillaye","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677794,"deputy_id":"PA793298","full_name":"Lionel Tivoli","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677812,"deputy_id":"PA840067","full_name":"Gabriel Tomatis","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677818,"deputy_id":"PA722102","full_name":"Annie Vidal","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"},{"position_id":5677908,"deputy_id":"PA607090","full_name":"Jean-Pierre Vigier","party_short":"PO838901","position":"pour"}]}