{"vote_id":"VTANR5L17V8617","voted_at":"2026-10-08T00:00:00","vote_title":"l'amendement n° 10 de Mme Nosbé à l'article unique de la proposition de loi visant à abroger les zones à faibles émissions-mobilités (première lecture).","result":"rejeté","votes_for":32,"votes_against":122,"abstentions":15,"total_voters":169,"summary_plain":"L'amendement visait à supprimer les zones à faibles émissions (ZFE) pour la mobilité, mais il a été rejeté, donc les ZFE restent en vigueur.","theme":"Transport & Logement","vote_type":"spo","dossier_id":"DLR5L17N54557","dossier":{"dossier_uid":"DLR5L17N54557","titre":"Abroger les zones à faibles émissions-mobilités","status":"en_commission","lois_url":"https://mon-elu.vercel.app/lois/DLR5L17N54557"},"ingested_at":null,"positions":[{"deputy_id":"PA841315","full_name":"Karim Benbrahim","party_short":"SOC","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA840997","full_name":"Benoît Biteau","party_short":"ECS","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA608264","full_name":"Colette Capdevielle","party_short":"SOC","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA794008","full_name":"Cyrielle Chatelain","party_short":"ECS","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA793452","full_name":"Hendrik Davi","party_short":"ECS","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA841633","full_name":"Peio Dufau","party_short":"SOC","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA794854","full_name":"Iñaki Echaniz","party_short":"SOC","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA840947","full_name":"Catherine Hervieu","party_short":"ECS","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA643192","full_name":"Chantal Jourdan","party_short":"SOC","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA841223","full_name":"Tristan Lahais","party_short":"ECS","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA794270","full_name":"Anna Pic","party_short":"SOC","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA841327","full_name":"Fabrice Roussel","party_short":"SOC","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA841243","full_name":"Sébastien Saint-Pasteur","party_short":"SOC","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA774960","full_name":"Isabelle Santiago","party_short":"SOC","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA841713","full_name":"Boris Tavernier","party_short":"ECS","position":"abstention"},{"deputy_id":"PA841495","full_name":"Maxime Amblard","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA796118","full_name":"Bénédicte Auzanot","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794562","full_name":"Philippe Ballard","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA842279","full_name":"Anchya Bamana","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793158","full_name":"José Beaurain","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA720362","full_name":"Belkhir Belhaddad","party_short":"SOC","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794434","full_name":"Christophe Bentz","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841645","full_name":"Théo Bernhardt","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA720822","full_name":"Bruno Bilde","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA720668","full_name":"Emmanuel Blairy","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA842183","full_name":"Benoît Blanchard","party_short":"HOR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA796042","full_name":"Frédéric Boccaletti","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793182","full_name":"Jorys Bovet","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794330","full_name":"Anthony Brosse","party_short":"EPR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793134","full_name":"Jérôme Buisson","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA795762","full_name":"Elie Califer","party_short":"SOC","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA721750","full_name":"Céline Calvez","party_short":"EPR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841973","full_name":"Pierre-Henri Carbonnel","party_short":"UDR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840075","full_name":"Eddy Casterman","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840701","full_name":"Bernard Chaix","party_short":"UDR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840107","full_name":"Bernard Chaumeil","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840721","full_name":"Marc Chavent","party_short":"UDR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840159","full_name":"Bruno Clavet","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793548","full_name":"Caroline Colombier","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793322","full_name":"Christelle D'Intorni","party_short":"UDR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA795644","full_name":"Nathalie Da Conceicao Carvalho","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA642988","full_name":"Hervé de Lépinau","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793166","full_name":"Jocelyn Dessigny","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794762","full_name":"Sandrine Dogor-Such","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793146","full_name":"Nicolas Dragon","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840135","full_name":"Alexandre Dufosset","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841351","full_name":"Emmanuel Duplessy","party_short":"ECS","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA842073","full_name":"Gaëtan Dussausaye","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841761","full_name":"Aurélien Dutremble","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840773","full_name":"Olivier Fayssat","party_short":"UDR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840195","full_name":"Muriel Fiol","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840143","full_name":"Guillaume Florquin","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794678","full_name":"Thierry Frappé","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841139","full_name":"Julien Gabarron","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793892","full_name":"Stéphanie Galzy","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841079","full_name":"Laurence Gardet","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA721024","full_name":"Anne Genetet","party_short":"EPR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841737","full_name":"Jonathan Gery","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841135","full_name":"Benoit Gilhet","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793832","full_name":"Yoann Gillet","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793102","full_name":"Christian Girard","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA718674","full_name":"Olga Givernet","party_short":"EPR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793362","full_name":"José Gonzalez","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794418","full_name":"Florence Goulet","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793592","full_name":"Géraldine Grangier","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840757","full_name":"Monique Griseti","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841451","full_name":"Julien Guibert","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794734","full_name":"Michel Guiniot","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793218","full_name":"Jordan Guitton","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA795900","full_name":"Marine Hamelet","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841709","full_name":"Emmanuelle Hoffman","party_short":"EPR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793632","full_name":"Timothée Houssin","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA842085","full_name":"Sébastien Humbert","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794598","full_name":"Laurent Jacobelli","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841439","full_name":"Pascal Jenft","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794030","full_name":"Alexis Jolly","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840745","full_name":"Édouard Jordan","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841837","full_name":"Robert Le Bourgeois","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA719412","full_name":"Sandrine Le Feur","party_short":"EPR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840857","full_name":"Nadine Lechon","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793290","full_name":"Gisèle Lelouis","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840983","full_name":"Bartolomé Lenoir","party_short":"UDR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA774958","full_name":"Gérard Leseul","party_short":"SOC","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793608","full_name":"Katiana Levavasseur","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840765","full_name":"Laurent Lhardit","party_short":"SOC","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841873","full_name":"Julien Limongi","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793672","full_name":"Christine Loir","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA721932","full_name":"Marie-France Lorho","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794590","full_name":"Alexandre Loubet","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841587","full_name":"David Magnier","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA717379","full_name":"Sylvain Maillard","party_short":"EPR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841563","full_name":"Claire Marais-Beuil","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794530","full_name":"Matthieu Marchio","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840837","full_name":"Pascal Markowsky","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841825","full_name":"Patrice Martin","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794770","full_name":"Michèle Martinez","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793354","full_name":"Joëlle Mélin","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA795786","full_name":"Yaël Ménaché","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794322","full_name":"Thomas Ménagé","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793852","full_name":"Pierre Meurin","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841769","full_name":"Éric Michoux","party_short":"UDR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA842147","full_name":"Christophe Mongardien","party_short":"EPR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840915","full_name":"Thibaut Monnier","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793696","full_name":"Serge Muller","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841107","full_name":"Jacques Oberti","party_short":"SOC","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA720334","full_name":"Jimmy Pahun","party_short":"DEM","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA759832","full_name":"Agnès Pannier-Runacher","party_short":"EPR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794670","full_name":"Caroline Parmentier","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841199","full_name":"Thierry Perez","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794582","full_name":"Kévin Pfeffer","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793656","full_name":"Lisette Pollet","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794994","full_name":"Alexandre Portier","party_short":"DR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA607553","full_name":"Dominique Potier","party_short":"SOC","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840955","full_name":"Pierre Pribetich","party_short":"SOC","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA795966","full_name":"Stéphane Rambaud","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793254","full_name":"Julien Rancoule","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841955","full_name":"Matthias Renault","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840657","full_name":"Sophie Ricourt Vaginay","party_short":"UDR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841981","full_name":"Catherine Rimbert","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA842227","full_name":"Joseph Rivière","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794442","full_name":"Laurence Robert-Dehault","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA795410","full_name":"Béatrice Roullaud","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA842097","full_name":"Sophie-Laurence Roy","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794894","full_name":"Anaïs Sabatini","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794570","full_name":"Alexandre Sabatou","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794954","full_name":"Emeric Salmon","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA796050","full_name":"Philippe Schreck","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA842255","full_name":"Anne Sicard","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794802","full_name":"Charles Sitzenstuhl","party_short":"EPR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841553","full_name":"Thierry Tesson","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA793298","full_name":"Lionel Tivoli","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840067","full_name":"Gabriel Tomatis","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840781","full_name":"Romain Tonussi","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA840685","full_name":"Vincent Trébuchet","party_short":"UDR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA878242","full_name":"Antoine Valentin","party_short":"UDR","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA794946","full_name":"Antoine Villedieu","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA841479","full_name":"Frédéric Weber","party_short":"RN","position":"contre"},{"deputy_id":"PA719024","full_name":"Christophe Blanchet","party_short":"DEM","position":"nonVotant"},{"deputy_id":"PA721908","full_name":"Yaël Braun-Pivet","party_short":"EPR","position":"nonVotant"},{"deputy_id":"PA794138","full_name":"Ségolène Amiot","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA795588","full_name":"Farida Amrani","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA842105","full_name":"Raphaël Arnault","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA841657","full_name":"Anaïs Belouassa-Cherifi","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA720430","full_name":"Ugo Bernalicis","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA793772","full_name":"Christophe Bex","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA720838","full_name":"Soumya Bourouaha","party_short":"GDR","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA795318","full_name":"Louis Boyard","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA841023","full_name":"Pierre-Yves Cadalen","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA793912","full_name":"Sylvain Carrière","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA842037","full_name":"Bérenger Cernon","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA793736","full_name":"Hadrien Clouet","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA794786","full_name":"Emmanuel Fernandes","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA796070","full_name":"Perceval Gaillard","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA842013","full_name":"Steevy Gustave","party_short":"ECS","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA841947","full_name":"Zahia Hamdane","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA794082","full_name":"Mathilde Hignet","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA795746","full_name":"Antoine Léaument","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA335612","full_name":"Jean-Paul Lecoq","party_short":"GDR","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA795298","full_name":"Jérôme Legavre","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA342384","full_name":"Élisa Martin","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA841215","full_name":"Marie Mesmeur","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA841191","full_name":"Sandrine Nosbé","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA793872","full_name":"Nathalie Oziol","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA720892","full_name":"Mathilde Panot","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA817211","full_name":"René Pilato","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA721062","full_name":"Jean-Hugues Ratenon","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA841845","full_name":"Arnaud Saint-Martin","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA795466","full_name":"Ersilia Soudais","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA793744","full_name":"Anne Stambach-Terrenoir","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA720952","full_name":"Aurélien Taché","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"},{"deputy_id":"PA794106","full_name":"Andrée Taurinya","party_short":"LFI","position":"pour"}]}